Thursday, July 21, 2011

Patikul (2011)

Patikul (Joel Lamangan, 2011)

There is no denying the sincerity of veteran director Joel Lamangan in making Patikul. Education is after all an issue that can never be overemphasized. It needs to be talked about because there is an alarming lack of it especially in the riskier and more remote areas in the Philippines. Patikul was born out of that very noble intention of educating the public on the deficiencies of the policy on education in the Philippines. Unfortunately, the film is as effective as a lousy kindergarten teacher teaching calculus to a room full of monkeys.

Patikul tells the story of Kan-Ague Elementary School in Patikul, Sulu. Two of Kan-Ague’s best students are chosen to compete in the region’s quiz bee. Determined to grab the top prize, the students prepare for the quiz bee with the help of the school’s supportive principal (Marvin Agustin) and teachers. However, the students get caught in the middle of the hostilities between the government and the terrorists.

Since Patikul borrows the name of an actual place for its title, one would logically expect Lamangan to shoot the film in that place. Instead, the film was shot in locations in Rizal and Cavite that could pass for the town of Patikul, or what Lamangan envisions Patikul in Sulu would be. The danger of the convenience-fueled resourcefulness is that it makes the film based on a certain interpretation of a place, an interpretation that is not unlike a ghastly stereotype. Thus, the film is erroneously emboldened by its pretty but empty visuals of rolling hills, dark forests, bustling town centers, and busy coffee farms. However, these locations are just stages, the characters are just performers, and the film is just an explicit exercise of fakery.

Sincerity and conviction are too different things. Patikul is a sincere film that lacks conviction. The confusion shows. The performances are obviously thinly inspired, grounded more on the need to get things done sure and fast than any genuine understanding of what their characters are going through. Agustin’s performance is predictably flat. The performances of Martin delos Santos and Angeli Nicole Sanoy, who gave life to the determined students who were chosen to compete for the quiz bee, are lacking in depth. The other supporting cast-members, with the probable exception of Glaiza de Castro who gives a modestly heartfelt depiction of one of the schoolteachers, are needless pretty faces and familiar names whose only contribution to the film is publicity.

The actors, however, are only acting out what the screenplay tells them to act out. Sadly, Kristoffer Brugada’s screenplay, which surprisingly won a Palanca award, is a horrendous mess. It is ridiculously talky, indulging in dialogue that makes more obvious the already obvious. Its desire to be “full of heart” (for a lack of a better phrase) is too put on, too manufactured.

Lamangan treats the screenplay with reverence it does not deserve. Thus, the result is this confused work whose only merit is that it seems to signal that the type of uninvolved filmmaking that Lamangan has gotten too used to from working as a hired gun for film studios and television stations can no longer work when the film that needs to be made involves the director’s sincerest advocacy that he longs to communicate. That said, Patikul is independent only by association, nothing more.

(Cross-published in Twitch.)


foursundaysofseptember said...

harsh. hahaha.

Don said...

May nag-walk out daw habang binabasa ang review na ito. LOLJK

Anonymous said...

problematic talaga ang set ng film. Puro tungkol kay 'allah' ang litanya ng mga characters pero you never ever saw any mosque in the exterior shots of the film. ive never been to sulu but I've been to maguindanao, and I remember parang every 100 meters ata ay may mosque. afaik, five times kung magdasal ang mga muslim pero hindi mo rin yun nakita sa film, at bilang sa sulu siya, wala ka man lang nakitang dagat.

ang problematic pa sa screenplay nagusap na nga ang dalawang character sa isang conflict (i.e. pagtigil sa pag-aaral nung isang character) may 3 scenes pa ata na same topic ang pinaguusapan ng ibang characters din. weird that it even won first prize in palanca. hindi naresearch mashado.

Anonymous said...

i've been to patikul, and from what i remember, magubat siya. i didn't attempt to watch the film anymore dahil trailer pa lang, i know what to expect already. at ang daming violent reactions ng mga nakapanood nito.

from what i've read to from the interview with the writer, he's never been to patikul either.

i agree with teddy co: only mindanao filmmakers should make films on mindanao. it's too complicated for a manilenyo to understand. especially since so many great filmmakers from mindanao have come out already.

Anonymous said...

Ha! What can you expect from Lamangan? He's a terrible director.

Anonymous said...

yes i agree to all comments,that this film will not really get the real score of patikul and its people.patikul is known to more beautiful beaches in sulu..the main livelihood of tao patikul is pagkokopra at ang kan ague elem school is just about 100 meters from the sea shore adjacent to taglibi the patikul poblacion..yes i agree that most of the households have not yet reach by electric grid.i am from patikul and i was born in patikul...