Thursday, August 09, 2007

Woman on the Beach (2006)



Woman on the Beach (Hong Sang-soo, 2006)
Korean Title: Haebyonui yoin

In one scene in Hong Sang-soo's Woman on the Beach, film director Jung-rae (Kim Seung-woo) draws a nebulous shape in his notepad; he draws three points in the shape which is connected to make a triangle. He explains to composer Mun-suk (Go Hyun-jung) the significance of the triangle (that it serves as a mnemonic tool that relates to an unsavory event in the past); he then draws several more points (all of which, he tells, pertain to more savory memories), and connects all the points making a complex polygon. He continues to explain that he is trying to remove himself from the triangle by expanding into the polygon in order to move on, and expects Mun-suk to help him.

The theory sounds a lot like bullshit; and Hong's intense detailing (complete with a zoom-in into the sketches in the notepad) makes it even more hilarious. However, this draws the line between Jung-rae and the all of Hong's embattled male characters; he is the only one who sought to escape the predestined rut by shaping up a rationale, a hypothesis behind the recurring events of his life. After watching the film of course, it doesn't seem that Jung-rae's clever rationalizations helped him; we again hear him (through a phone call to Mun-suk) explain how much he misses the girl, and how his leaving her is merely a retreat, a sign of weakness.

Woman in the Beach has Hong in his most geometric (and I believe Hong is a director who fancies triangles, structures, and angles to fetishistic proportions --- his films have always had love triangles and a meticulous attention to geometric blocking and detailed structuring). He starts out with a single love triangle (between Chang-wook (Kim Tae-woo), Mun-suk and Jung-rae). Observe Hong's aesthetics wherein he frequently uses zooms to negate one character, thus bringing attention to a couple, and then zooms out, to reveal the complete triangle. But well within the triangle of the first half of the film, are other off-screen triangles (Chang-wook is married but has Mun-suk as a girlfriend-on-the-side; Jung-rae is a recent divorcee).

The second half of the film has Hong complicating the triangle he has already made us familiar with, by introducing further characters such as Sun-hee (Song Seon-mi), a vacationer who is interviewed by a director, and her friend. We realize that Hong intends to complicate his themes (which makes Woman on the Beach into a more ambitious film compared to his previous efforts which have neatly packaged love triangles with very little complications --- Virgin Stripped Bare By Her Bachelors (2000), Woman is the Future of Man (2004), Tale of Cinema (2005)). Triangles start overlapping, and identical points to the triangles start commingling, resulting into unexpected statements of humanity in the face of complex relationships.

What's the point of Hong's obsession with structures, shapes and the number three (love triangles, the three trees, trees which made Jung-rae knelt to, etc.)? We go back to one of the many themes (aside from the perpetual filmmaker-protagonists, the immature male characters, the drunken confessionals, the frank yet lifeless portrayals of copulation) that connect Hong's cinema. His structures, his persistence with basic mathematical imputations are the connective tissue that relate memory to human experiences and relationships, which he so nonchalantly paints in his films. Hong would always signal remembrance (the events and objects that connect the two divisions of the film, like the dog in the beach or the waiter offended by Jung-rae's impertinence; places which appear twice and invite remembrance like the rest stop or the empty room wherein Jung-rae and Mun-suk first had sex), as made more apparent by the chapters and the meticulousness to numerical detail.

The overlapping triangles seem to be residues of unshelled memories; they are mere repetitions of mistakes made or inflicted in the past, continuously haunting those chained to it (which almost all of Hong's characters are). The interesting bit about Woman on the Beach is that finally, Hong has created a character is now aware of the torturous cycles in life and relationships inflicted by the inescapable grasps of memory and tried to find a way out of it, flawed and convoluted as it may seem.

Wednesday, August 08, 2007

Philippine Cinema on the Verge of Redemption


from Sherad Sanchez's Huling Balyan ng Buhi (Woven Stories of the Other)

Philippine Cinema on the Verge of Redemption
by Francis Joseph Cruz

Nine Best Digital Films

My list would have been different. Lav Diaz’s Heremias (2006; a nine-hour epic about an ox-cart driver on a spiritual journey), Dennis Marasigan’s Sa North Diversion Road (On the North Diversion Road, 2005; a road trip through the despair of a dying marriage), Ato Bautista’s Sa Aking Pagkagising Mula sa Kamulatan (My Awakening From Consciousness, 2005; a powerful yet flawed film of connected stories of angst-ridden teens), Khavn dela Cruz’s Squatterpunk (2006; a video-collage of scenes shot in the slums set into motion by the music of the aptly-named band, The Brockas), and most recently Jade Castro’s Endo (2007; a lovely romance set in a world of temporary contractual workers) would possibly make the cut.

It’s unfortunate that there’s only one documentary in the list. Raya Martin’s The Island at the End of the World (2005; a fascinating immersion on the Ivatans of Batanes as shown by juvenile inmates) and Ditsi Carolino’s Bunso (The Youngest, 2005; a brave expose on the futility of both our judicial and penal systems, as shown by the experiences of juvenile inmates) are all powerful documentaries. More surprising is the lack of genre films. Rico Ilarde’s Sa Ilalim ng Cogon (Beneath the Cogon¸ 2005; a nightmarish tale of a man-on-the-run, a mysterious lass, and a monster hiding beneath a forest of tall grass), Erik Matti’s Pa-Siyam (2004; although studio-financed, it is a film shot in digital video, about siblings unraveling the mysteries behind their mother’s death) and Mario Cornejo & Monster Jimenez’s Big Time (2005; two petty crooks trapped in a scheme bigger than their ambitions) are all worthy candidates.

The nine digital films in the program, selected through a series of surveys, are all worthy entries. These are the films that do not need the oft-used and bastardized label of “indie” to legitimize their existence.

Films About Children

More than half of Filipinos are children which is probably the reason Philippine cinema has an infatuation with children’s tales. More than the statistics, films about children always focus on coming-of-age, of innocence on the verge of a sudden awakening, of the beauty of naiveté in the midst of the world’s realities.

In Mes de Guzman’s Ang Daan Patungong Kalimugtong (The Road to Kalimugtong, 2005), two children wake up to their daily task of walking miles to reach their school. The film unravels like a humble ode to those struggling to traverse that barricaded road to their meager ambitions. It’s brilliant in its narrative simplicity yet it carries with it a subtle indictment of the ills of an underfunded public education system.

The unlikely heroine of Brillante Mendoza’s Manoro (The Teacher, 2006), young Jonalyn, has the daunting task of teaching the members of her Aeta tribe to write in time for the presidential elections. Through her journey to find her grandfather (who is more interested in hunting for food than taking part in the elections), she awakens to the futility of modern democratic processes, especially to their tribe, a mere dot in the myriad of problems plaguing the nation.

Ang Pagdadalaga ni Maximo Oliveros (The Blossoming of Maximo Oliveros, 2005) sparked public consciousness on the unlimited possibilities of the digital medium by winning hordes of awards and recognition from several film festivals here and abroad. Auraeus Solito’s first feature carefully puts in the center of the film a fragile romance between an honest cop and adorable Maxie. In a sequence borrowed from Carol Reed’s The Third Man, we become witnesses of the pre-pubescent gay boy’s quickened and heartbreaking blossoming in a world as dirty as the trash-clogged canals shown in the film’s start.

Films About Poverty

Poverty is more often than not, a primary ingredient in Philippine cinema. Being poor is prima facie evidence of being the underdog and filmgoers’ hearts ache for the underdog. Lino Brocka turned poverty into his canvass; it is the impetus for the bizarre love triangle in Insiang (1976), for the Manila-bound exodus of Ligaya in Maynila sa Kuko ng Liwanag (Manila in the Claws of Neon, 1975), and for the subjugation of the men to near-nude grinding in Macho Dancer (1988). Digital cinema has embraced the decades-old trope with a fresh approach.

Riles (Life on the Tracks, 2003) is the lone documentary in the program. Ditsi Carolino’s unobtrusive camera relentlessly follows the Renomerons during their final days living in a makeshift shack a meter away from the railroad tracks. Of course, the true movers of the documentary are Carolino’s subjects: Eddie, the husband with pitch-perfect comic timing and Pen, whose consistent nagging is made charming by her fortitude against the many illnesses she is feeling. The result of Carolino’s sincere storytelling and the Renomerons’ willingness to have their lives immortalized in digital video is a moving portrait of survival and resilience in the midst of inhumane living conditions.

Like Riles, Jeffrey Jeturian’s Kubrador (The Bet Collector, 2006) centers on the resiliency of its main character Amy, a bet collector for an illegal numbers game. Her profession dictates that she be at the mercy of fate as her every transaction, each little mistake invites death. Always moving forward and with frequent apparitions from his dead soldier son, it takes a chance encounter with death for her to pause, and realize how close she is to the grave.

New Visions

A cinematic revolution that merely exchanges 35mm for the cheap conveniences of digital video can hardly be called as a true revolution. The conventions of narrative cinema should be broken, and new stories be told.

If cinema is terrorism, as John Torres’ Todo Todo Teros forwards, then the Philippines would be its ideal headquarters. Torres populates his film with familiar faces and places: directors Lav Diaz, Khavn dela Cruz, and Regiben Romana are artist-terrorist hybrids and pubs and concert venues their dangerous lairs. However, that’s just the brilliant backdrop of this essentially romantic tale of an artist deeply in love with Olga, his Russian tour guide, at the expense of his desperate wife. That scene where the wife weeps as footages of her husband and Olga sharing moments with each other are projected over each and every corner of that paranoid metropolis is something that will forever be etched in my cinematic consciousness.

Sherad Anthony Sanchez’s Huling Balyan ng Buhi (Woven Stories of the Other, 2006) was made with seed money provided by Cinema One, a cable network under the Lopez Family-owned conglomerate. It is the best film to ever be funded out of the pockets of Lopezes (a daunting feat since the family owns one of the biggest film studios in the country). A boy and a girl on a search, a band of Communist fighters, a camp of government troops, their neighbor, a priestess of a dying tradition --- these are the threads that are weaved to form the mysterious and magical, subversive yet lyrical tale of the marginalized.

Raya Martin’s Maicling Pelicula ng Ysang Indio Nacional (A Short Film About the Indio Nacional, 2005) presupposes a film culture that preceded the concept of nationhood. Vignettes of everyday functions (quite subversive in its subtle humor; children enchanted by an eclipse and churchgoing chores) under Spanish rule, transforming into the footholds of an impending revolution are successively shown, accompanied by live music (from a repertoire chosen personally by Martin). The clever footages are given significance by the film’s haunting first part: a woman unable to sleep wakes up her husband and begs for a story; the story alludes to the melancholy of a nation deprived of identity and history, symbolized by the woman deprived of her sleep.

Lav Diaz’s Ebolusyon ng Isang Pamilyang Pilipino (Evolution of a Filipino Family, 2004) took a decade to make (it includes both 16mm and digital video footage). Clocking at eleven hours, the film is a monumental examination of two families struggling through the political and economic change brought about by history. The middle entry to his Filipino Trilogy (which includes Batang West Side (West Side Avenue, 2002) and Heremias), the film establishes Diaz as one of the most unique voices in contemporary cinema.

Like the fractured interconnected souls of Diaz’s Ebolusyon ng Isang Pamilyang Pilipino, our cinema is on the verge of a beautiful redemption. Young filmmakers like Martin, Sanchez, Torres, and many more waiting to be discovered have taken into their hands the role of pioneers of this new Philippine cinema. Truly, we are living in exciting times.

******
This article was written for the 9th Cinemanila International Film Festival catalogue. Unfortunately, the program of "Nine Best Digital Films" was shelved, along with this article. It has found a new home in my blog.
The film festival runs from August 9 to 19 in the Gateway Mall in Quezon City, and August 17 to 19 in Boracay Island.

******
I also urge you to check Noel Vera's List of 100 Best Filipino Films.

Monday, August 06, 2007

48 Oras (1950)



48 Oras (Gerardo de Leon, 1950)
English Title: 48 Hours

The film starts with an attempted prison escape, wonderfully directed by Gerardo de Leon. Two men are chased by prison guards, and the warden is alarmed of the planned escape and orders the guards to bring them back at all costs. A treacherous corner frustrates their escape as prison guards block their way to recapture them and bring them back to the warden. The two men are Carding (Rogelio dela Rosa) and Melchor (Enrico Pimentel), innocent yet convicted for the death of Carding's wife and mother, respectively. The plot follows Carding as he tries to prove his innocence by escaping from the prison then, finding the true perpetrator of the heinous crime.

It's a very good film. De Leon directs with both practical and aesthetic flourish. The action scenes are intense. The battle scenes in Bataan followed by a daring escape from their Japanese captors is filmed with such astounding kinetic energy. De Leon would know where to put his camera to provide the most practical canvass; like where we see a bridge (where the Japanese soldiers are firing at the prisoners) and the river (wherein the prisoners are huddled together and trying to dodge bullets); or when the prisoners are finally captured and are about to meet their fate (we see the Japanese soldiers with their rifles pointed) only to be disrupted by the rescuers who annihilate the Japanese soldiers.

The second prison escape is even more exciting. It all begins with careful whispers between the inmates culminating to the actual escape where the inmates dodge the searchlights and the prison guards. Nearing a successful escape, an inmate gets left behind which alerts the entire prison; bullets are shot feverishly and every one of the inmates are either dead or captured, except for Carding.

It's not only the singular set pieces that contribute to the film's tense character. The entirety of the film itself is an engaging chase against time. Carding, mortally wounded, has only forty eight hours to bring out the truth behind his wife's murder. His dilemma is two-fold: his mortal wound would only allow him to live for the said amount of time, and it is also the same amount of time until Melchor is executed.

De Leon sprinkles the film with plenty of close-calls, like the scene where a mumbling doctor who sneaks away to alarm the police of the escaped felon; or that tense confrontation between Carding and the goons of Andres (Oscar Keesee), the real murderer and treacherous war buddy of Carding, or Carding's battle with death, only to be rescued by a trustworthy priest. De Leon clearly understands the requirements of the genre and he sufficiently addresses such, draping the film with sublime attention and detail that is required of film noir.

The final confrontation is stylish. Set in an office filled with clocks, Andres has Carding's kid as hostage and Carding only has his wit and an injured shoulder to direct his precious gun with. De Leon again showcases his aesthetic and practical sensibilities (with a tinge of inspiration from John Ford); which makes this confrontation extremely exciting. Light is used as an essential element, bullets aren't perpetual commodities, emotions are heightened (invested from the many moments de Leon allows us to believe and empathize with his characters), and we become aware of the time element (this confrontation is a close call; and would be the fateful end or start to him and Melchor's life). De Leon utilizes punctuality in that climactic confrontation (although visually stylish, de Leon does not overindulge in style and keeps the action rolling and unpunctuated).

Of course, it ends wonderfully and happily (Carding reunites with his son, and is regarded the brave soldier instead of a criminal). 48 Oras (48 Hours) is such an exhilarating experience; too bad it'll probably turn into a vinegary mess in a decade's time, or less.

Sunday, August 05, 2007

Badjao (1957)



Badjao (Lamberto Avellana, 1957)

As a romanticized document of two distinct cultures, the Badjao and Tausog tribes of Mindanao, Lamberto Avellana's Badjao is simply spectacular. It begins with a ritual, probably barbaric and shocking to our homogenized world. A baby is born to the pagan sea-faring Badjaos. The baby is then thrown into the sea, and a couple of Badjao men would dive into the sea to save the baby from drowning. A man would rise victorious carrying the baby and delivering it to the tribal chief (Pedro Faustino); and the baby, newest member is finally presented to the tribe.

We get a feel of their lifestyle through Avellana's curious and meticulous eye: the sense of justice of the Muslim Tausogs (there's a scene wherein the datu sentences a wrongdoer to pay the victim money and to be inflicted a slap that would erase all evidence of the wrongdoing); the intricate marriage vows; the codes of honor and bonds of dignity among and between these people; the clockwork commerce wherein the Badjaos supply the Tausogs pearls, and the latter supplies the rest of the world such pearls through shrewd middlemen.

The story, about Hassan (Tony Santos), a Badjao prince, who falls in love with Bal-Amai (Rosa Rosal), niece of the Tausog datu (Joseph de Cordova), is set in an age of the cultural inequality that has characterized the tensions that divide the two tribes. The vast cultural conflicts would lead Hassan to choose between his heritage and his heart. He chooses his heart and converts to Islam and cleansing himself of his Badjao heritage, and deciding to live as a farmer with Bal-Amai within the Tausog tribe. This decision leads to his banishment from the Badjao tribe.

It's a powerful picture, one that is very universal and human despite being set against the exoticized landscapes and seascapes of Mindanao. It pits traditions of honor, justice and civility of the two tribes, with sources of human fallibility like greed, prejudice and treachery. Characters are tested: Hassan with his decision to withdraw from the Badjao tribe and adopt Tausog culture; the datu who is blinded enough by the allure of money to descend to the level of blunt treachery; Bal-Amai with her insistence of making Hassan forget his roots.

Avellana always fills his scenes with intricacies and details. The Tausog town, with its port of bamboo scaffolds to the marketplace wherein the air of racism is quite apparent, is an impressively built set. Much more spectacular are the boats of the Badjaos: at night, we see these floating boats with their respective lighted torches, like will-o-wisps floating against the night sky. The action scenes are equally gripping: Jiriki (Vic Silayan), the datu's treacherous adviser, and Hassan's duel in the rock beach is nail-bitingly exciting; Muslim kris pitted against Badjao forked staff; and the two fighters end up rolling in the rocks. Avellana understands the mechanics of the fights (the same way he coherently choreographs the early duels in the Tausog town) and commits to celluloid such visceral intensity.

The film's final scene, a revisit of the ritual in the beginning, we begin to understand the rationale and humanity underneath the culture-specific ritual. We become more open to the similarities that bind us as a single people despite the diversity in religion, culture, and traditions. Badjao is a beautiful and intense film, probably the best and most ambitious Avellana made. Avellana, although a Catholic filmmaker and working under the grips of a commercial studio, paints a portrait of both Muslim and tribal cultures with forceful accuracy and affecting sensitivity.

Saturday, August 04, 2007

La Paloma: Ang Kalapating Ligaw (1974)



La Paloma: Ang Kalapating Ligaw (Joey Gosiengfiao, 1974)
English Title: La Paloma: The Lost Dove

In La Paloma: Ang Kalapating Ligaw (La Paloma: The Lost Dove), Joey Gosiengfiao stages a three-way war for the estate left behind by Don Lorenzo, who died supposedly by suicide. Anida (Vina Cansino), the pious and righteous widow, Paloma (Celia Rodriguez), actress and paramour of the deceased, and Soledad (Mona Lisa), Lorenzo's mother. They all have their reasons: Anida, to get what she thinks she deserves as suffering wife to a philandering husband; Paloma, to concretize the amor in her love affair with Don Lorenzo; and Soledad, for mere survival since her stay in the estate was merely tolerated by Anida.

It's quite an elegant picture, still hilariously funny but succumbing to vaporous wit and indulgent humor. It offers a satirical stab at the hypocricy of high society (at those times, very much coinciding with fervent religiosity). The moment Paloma steps into the mansion, tensions rise. Anida finally finds a formidable competitor (probably tired of pushing Soledad around with her mean gazes and vicious remarks). The rest of the mourners are even more shocked that a scandalous paramour has the guts to invade on a familial ritual, and probably scared that a woman of ill-repute (Paloma is an actress in Manila, and was rumored to be involved in several illicit affairs) would pollute the religiosity and purity of their town. Soledad, on the other hand, finds her trump card and cements her bargaining position.

Gosiengfiao has always been compared to foreign camp-master such as Pedro Almodovar or John Waters, but this early Gosiengfiao proves that his canvass is far more richer. La Paloma has Gosiengfiao playing with Buñuelian surrealism --- when Paloma walks at night to find Lorenzo's garden crawling with cockroaches and toads (elaborate statues and fountains are desecrated by those creepy crawlers), you know that Gosiengfiao is working at another level. Even the interiors of the mansion, with its high ceilings and staircases, have a sense of depleted morality --- empty, cold, and on the verge of both physical and moral deterioration.

Joel (Orestes Ojeda), a traveling gardener and guitarist arrives one day and offers his services to the embattled household. Anida's test is rather simple: make one flower bloom in the doomed garden. Joel instead turns his attention on Paloma, exhausted in defending her love for Lorenzo, and on the verge of a conversion to piety orchestrated by Anida, which practically consumes the life out of the free-spirited Paloma. Paloma is in the middle of that tug-of-war between Anida's persistent exorcism of Paloma's past and Joel's manly and amorous serenades.

The heat of the war culminates in court (there is literal heat as there's a lot of perspiring, fanning, and jeering crowds) where Paloma defends her stake in Lorenzo's estate and heart, and Anida uses her state as grieving widow to a philandering husband as a plea to the sentiments of the righteous mob. The several testimonies are all defiantly delivered pieces of oratory; which makes the entire judicial exercise exciting. Themes are weeded out from the film's extrinsic kitsch and humor --- we become aware that there's more to Paloma's character than a clawing and greedy diva; that she hides an emotional void that only the men she loved can fill. Gosiengfiao climaxes the film with a well-executed twist, ending the film with appropriate murderous intentions from the battle's rotting participants.

I make it sound like La Paloma is serious art. I don't think it is. It is however distinctly Gosiengfiao (and the numerous exchanges of elitistly witty and funny pieces of dialouge between the widow and the paramour (or at times, the mother) would make any audience rolling with laughter; or Joel's seductive poses (complete with suspenders and a guitar on his back, and a badly-rendered song to boot --- all preceding the Latino gardeners of Desperate Housewives)) --- commercial fare but surpasses the limits of being an object of commodity by the director's cinematic flair.

Friday, August 03, 2007

Kundiman ng Lahi (1959)



Kundiman ng Lahi (Lamberto Avellana, 1959)
English Title: Song of the Race

The first image we see in Lamberto Avellana's Kundiman ng Lahi (Song of the Race) is the rhythmic grinding of grain to fine flour. There are no extravagant visuals or swelling music to accompany the opening credits. Just that, the sound of repeated pounding and the image of the mortar and pestle being utilized. It's a beautiful introduction, very simple yet appropriate in detailing the overall thrust of Avellana's film wherein a barrio lass who is dealt with fate's repetitive pounding, and despite such, survives triumphantly.

We then hear the beautiful melody of Nicanor Abelardo's song. Through the narration by Isang (Charito Solis), we learn that it is the town fiesta. We see Isang with her sweetheart Tonyo (Eddie Rodriguez) in gleeful celebration before being dealt with news of the impending death of her mother. Orphaned, she is left to the whims and cruel shrewdness of her aunt (Rosa Aguirre) and step-uncle (Joseph de Cordova). In order to pay for her mother's debts and the mortgage attached to the land she has inherited, she first sews, before being lured into the cabarets, wherein she retains her moral uprightness despite the seediness of her profession.

Avellana's approach is clearly genteel, but never prude. There's a subtle sensuality to Avellana's filmmaking: the way he dresses and imagines Isang to complete the picture of nubile and seductive innocence (after the mother's death, you first see Isang dressed in a sexy black dress, her cleavage peeking and her wavy hair overflowing with sensual invitations), enough to make the step-uncle's insistent gestural innuendos (a curious tapping of his fingers in Isang's naked arm, or the momentary yet stolen glances of Isang's cleavage) understandable, and even forgiveable. It is that difficult balancing act that makes Kundiman ng Lahi engrossing: that the sexy vixen is the personification of well-regarded Filipina virtues of domesticity, propriety, purity and innocence.

Avellana also masterfully captures the allure of progress. Jaime (Vic Silayan) takes Isang for a ride to Manila. We see the rapid yet memorable images of the city through the car ride (the bright lights and the rows of car), and more importantly, the fascination of Isang (as shown by Solis' sparkling face and her apt narration). Also, Tonyo forgoes the slow income of working the land to the monthly salaries and the huge machineries of a rock quarry. Avellana depicts progress as an inevitable change that is happening.

How do these Filipina virtues factor in a nation that embraces progress and materialism? We witness Isang traverse the all-too-familiar path leading to corruption (extreme poverty, cruelty by her guardians, being employed in a cabaret, having a rich, urbane suitor). We also witness how she has always survive through the trials by clinging on the same virtues (her regard for familial and marital ties) that is so easy to discard amidst the calls of modernity. Avellana (and of course the very righteous stance of LVN Studios) seems to be establishing that such virtues are not antiquated by progress or the several beatings and hardships that accompany modernity.

The film closes with Tonyo and Isang reunited, with her reformed aunt and their baby. We are reminded of the opening image; that notwithstanding the ease and allure progress has provided them, there's no better way to make flour than by pounding the grain with meticulous rhythm, difficult and painstaking as it may seem. Life is not very different.

Bedspacers (1980)



Bedspacers (Joey Gosiengfiao, 1980)

The late great Joey Gosiengfiao is more than a director of campy movies, he is also a very fascinating filmmaker with an eye for structures compounded with a sincere heart for his art (which translates very well into his films). There's no denying that the man has both wit and humor (as anybody who has seen Temptation Island (1981), with its shipwrecked characters and their palpable lust for both flesh and food, would agree). There's something more to Gosiengfiao though than the glamor poses of his bikini-clad beauties and the witty one-liners thrown with elitist stance.

Bedspacers is Gosiengfiao's favorite work because it allowed him to explore the wealth of themes that compounded college life (which he has fond memories of). The film juggles the stories of several university students --- Nadia (a sublime performance by Alma Moreno), who gathers funds for her schooling by prostituting herself; Margot (Rio Locsin), a social climber who parades around in posh parties to integrate herself in that exclusive social stratum; Dindo (Mark Gil), a student-thespian who is struggling with his stage role; and a lass (Amy Austria) plucked from the province to study in the city and balances the the needs of her boyfriend and her very conservative ways; and their respective partners (played by Al Tantay, the dazzling Deborah Sun, and Orestes Ojeda).

It is of course, like all of Gosiengfiao's films, has scenes overflowing with camp, like the three-way cat fight that leads to Margot's wet blouse being torn into bits; or the several episodes of all-male or all-female bonding in their respective dormitories; or when Nadia is slapped in the rain; or when Deborah Sun's professor steps on the roses given to her; or that sequence wherein Margot sneaks her way through a posh party (where she mistakenly refers to chicken as Peking duck) with her facade of elitist snobbery.

What impresses me is Gosiengfiao's very structural approach to the film, both thematically and visually, and sometimes all at once. The film is easily dismissable because of its juvenile settings and its preachy demeanor, but there's a hint of brilliance in Gosiengfiao's filmmaking here. The term bedspacers refers to those tenants (mostly students or young workers) who merely rent beds in overcramped dormitories, the purpose of course is to save money. It is that concept of proximity that astounds me: these tenants literally sleep a few inches from each other; share a communal bathroom; the male and female dormitories divided by a narrow alleyway (the bedspacers can literally see what's happening in the other dormitory).

Gosiengfiao breaks these perceived proximities. Education is supposedly the equalizing factor in a democratic nation. In Bedspacers, Gosiengfiao attacks the institution for its elitism and hypocrisy --- he, of course, takes the side of the students and unfolds their dilemmas with sympathy. More specifically, Gosiengfiao dissects his scenes with detailed reverence to enunciate severance and emotional distance: observe how he separates his characters during key sequences --- in that tender scene wherein Al Tantay's character discovers Nadia's whoring (Gosiengfiao uses a division in the wall to literally separate the two characters); or when Amy Austria's character tells her boyfriend she is pregnant (we only see the characters faces in the circular mirrors of the bar, there's a literal space in between the two lovers); or when Margot disowns her mother (we see Margot's face through the mirror, while the mother is shown in a different space); or when Lindo professes his adoration for his professor (the two are separated by a bookshelf, and later by that distance made by their ladders).

There's a visual and thematic elegance to Gosiengfiao's filmmaking that gets overshadowed by the labels we have given the man (King of Camp, etc.). True, he defers to directors Lino Brocka or Ishmael Bernal in tackling issues of supposed import and relevance (such as poverty or politics), but in that overcrowded niche of commercial filmmaking (which is most probably the reason why his praised are received belatedly) wherein he worked comfortably and at ease (with producers and other filmmakers), he has excelled and made works that transcend the limitations of profit-making. I've only seen a fraction of Gosiengfiao's ouvre, but Bedspacers definitely is one of his most accomplished works.

Thursday, August 02, 2007

Mutya ng Pasig (1950)



Mutya ng Pasig (Richard Abelardo, 1950)
English Title: Muse of Pasig

Part of the charm of watching Richard Abelardo’s Ang Mutya ng Pasig (Muse of Pasig) today, is witnessing the habitable state of the Pasig River a few decades ago. The film opens during the town’s fiesta --- the citizenry in hordes (some of them floating in the river’s sparkling waters; unthinkable today since the waters have lost its sparkle with the accumulation of grease, trash, and other stuff throughout the years) celebrating Mercedes (Rebecca Gonzalez) and Delfin (Roger Nite), the lovely couple crowned as the fiesta’s muse and escort, respectively.

The film follows the turn of events that would separate Delfin from Mercedes, who ends up marrying Don Modesto (Jose Padilla, Jr.), the town’s doctor who harbors a secret affection for the town muse. Tormented by jealousy and uncertainty, Don Modesto banishes Mercedes and their newborn baby (characterized with a birthmark; not a mere plot contrivance since it also facilitates Modesto’s questioning of the child’s paternity when he says the child was born under shadowy circumstances, thus the birthmark). The baby grows up (now played by the Delia Razon), and is named Consuelo by the kindly couple (played by Tolindoy and Angge, comedians with perfect wit and comedic timing) who found her floating in the river and adopted her, and becomes the sweetheart of Basilio (Teody Belarmino), coincidentally the son of Delfin.

The film’s much more than a time capsule of the former luster of Manila's most prominent river. It’s actually a lovely confection --- melodrama in heaps with a tinge of the surreal (Mercedes’ face appearing from the floating water lilies in the river; Don Modesto relives his unjustified banishment of Mercedes through what looks like a thought bubble) and the folkloric (the film is weaved from the tale of a mermaid who appears in the river at night, luring men to their deaths through her beautiful singing). It’s all balanced carefully by Abelardo, who deftly tells the story with genteel frankness (much like a storybook unfolding with exciting and imaginative vigor).

Mercedes’ apparitions are hauntingly beautiful. She appears garbed in an elaborate dress singing the titular song (composed by Nicanor Abelardo, brother of the director and treasured musician); the intricate melody can only be heard by those who matter (Don Modesto who sadly peers from his window; Consuelo who is mysteriously drawn to the river and the water lilies that populate its waters; later, to Basilio and those looking for her). It’s a lovely diversion from folkloric tradition --- the mermaid’s allure to eager men becomes a desperate wife and mother’s pleas to correct the errors of the past.

You understand the pain, and even that endless longing, that withstands death, that withstands the cruelty of her banishment (one of the film's most exciting and visually powerful sequences is when Mercedes is sent away --- she runs underneath the violent downpour of rain, and chased by Don Modesto's dog through the river banks).

Mutya ng Pasig may not be as sleek as the clever dramas of our contemporary film age (you can’t deny that there are sequences which hamper the film’s flow). However, its timeless feel is undeniable. There’ll always be a lingering sense of wonderment whenever the story unfolds; or a sudden rush of excitement when the father is reunited with his daughter; or that well-deserved gush of emotions when the ailments caused by human fallibility is suddenly cured, and forgiven. It is, quite simply, magical.

Malvarosa (1958)



Malvarosa (Gregorio Fernandez, 1958)

Gregorio Fernandez's Malvarosa is the acknowledged inspiration behind Auraeus Solito's Ang Pagdadalaga ni Maximo Oliveros (The Blossoming of Maximo Oliveros, 2005), the story of a gay boy who does the household work for his family of petty crooks. It’s originally a comic book by Clodualdo del Mundo Sr. (father of Doy del Mundo, screenwriter of much of Mike de Leon’s films such as Itim (The Rites of May, 1976) and Kisapmata (Blink of an Eye, 1982), and Lino Brocka’s Maynila: Sa Mga Kuko ng Liwanag (Manila in the Claws of Neon, 1975)). Adapted into a screenplay by Consuelo Osorio, and realized into a beautifully weaved film by Fernandez, who has this uncanny ability of turning pulp goodness into visually fascinating templates of humanity.

Fernandez frames his scenes with intelligence --- you admire how scenes are blocked in a way that is practical, aesthetically pleasing, and also elicits themes (the brothers’ dominance over their servant sister (as shown in the first few scenes where we see her doing the laundry of her brothers; each brother is then introduced visually as imposing figures towering over her meager frame)).

Rosa (Charito Solis) is the youngest, and the only female in a brood of six. As typical of a Filipino family, she has been delegated the task of keeping the house in order, while her parents gamble and drink, and her siblings gallivant or become preoccupied with their own selfish interests. Her fate (and this is pretty much emphasized by the film’s introduction, brisk and concise: the mother (Rebecca del Rio) asks her fortune from a soothsayer who tells her that she will be widowed, but will have five sons and a single daughter) is to be intertwined in her familial duties (especially when her mother becomes insane upon the death of her father). Her only consolation is Avelino (Eddie Rodriguez), her only brother who seems to have an ambition, and her boyfriend Candido (Leroy Salvador), who is indefatigable in persuading her to marry and start a new life.

Most interesting is how Fernandez was able to breathe life into the family’s community, which is an additional character in itself, a lingering burden upon the many burdens Rosa has to carry. The setting aggravates the predicaments --- Alberto (Carlos Padilla, Jr.), Rosa’s older brother who uncharacteristically works under the parish priest, has to weed out the reputation of his family in the community in order to satisfy his romantic longings; Rosa is also a victim of this societal indignation (in that scene where Vedasto (Rey Ruiz), the lazy yet enterprising brother, declares to the neighborhood how Rosa supposedly submitted herself to impurity, Rosa succumbs to the shame and embarrassment), as well as the victim of everything from fate, to callous siblings, to the Filipino patriarchy.

That glimmer of hope for Rosa rests in a land (gorgeous piece of unoccupied real estate, lovingly photographed with all its picturesque trees and farms; it’s a postcard image of a perfect future), that is far from the rumor mongering, the perpetuated squalor, and the misplaced righteousness of the slums. It seems though that Rosa is as tied to their house in the slums as to her family; which makes the film’s ending where the house is burned, an apt transition to the perfect little ending (where the remaining characters are huddled together in hopes of a brighter future). Now that the roots have disappeared and traces of the past have vanished, a chance for a new life is gained. I completely buy it --- it’s a fairy tale ending that is deserved and ripe with reasons.

Wednesday, August 01, 2007

CinoMalaya?



CinoMalaya?
English Translation: Who's Free?

Pardon the pun (Thanks to Raya for the lovely picture; his blog also has essays on the fallacy of the film festival worth reading: here and here). It delighted me to see the usually empty spaces of the Cultural Center of the Philippines full of people, idly chatting about the films they just saw in the Cinemalaya Film Festival. It shows promise that alongside the so-called independence in filmmaking, there is also a burgeoning reception to these films (at least from the new generation). Now that there's reception, what's next? Do we sit idly and wait for the so-called independent movement to fizzle and become the mainstream? That's what I fear, and that's why I invite everyone to talk about the films you've seen (mainstream, independent, Hollywood, foreign) in whatever way you can (feminist, homosexual, Marxist, personal readings are most welcome; educate yourself with what's readily unavailable in our shores (through Cinamanila, or those series of screenings, DVDs (legit or not)): a blog is free, access to the internet is cheap, your contribution to Philippine cinema is invaluable). Now that Philippine cinema is supposedly free, it is the audience's turn to be liberated from pre-conceived notions on how to read cinema (read: mere exercise for the eyes).

I thought that the following conversation is an interesting discussion, and I am inviting online lurkers to take part in the discourse. Feel free to take part in the discussion. I am copying the bulk of the discussion here, but one may read everything in my thoughts on Jim Libiran's Tribu (2007):

Rich:

Kid, you got what it takes to be a critic... Like Oggs said, everybody's a critic... I just don't think that, Oggs, you are. Your righteous criticisms in some of your films are so outstandingly in denial beyond cinematic comparison. You approach it with a verbalistic observation, or atleast I think it is, towards a merely non-idealistic art. Altman, Spielberg, Lee, Zwick, Macinzski, Stolav, Chung, Rosario, Rodriguez, Polate, Teranitti, Pussini, and Howard... are only a handful of the greatests... they are not Directors...they are Filmmakers... Big difference...what's my point Oggs? My point is what Kid was trying to say...there's merely no comparison between any of them.. They have their own style like a volcano has its own. The late Bob Altman had a different brush like of Libiran's, but ..they are both artists. Artists at their own peds.

Kid's point was to merely circumcise the "critic" that can easily be based on your observation and wonderment on how it is easy for some (Oggs) and hard for others (Kid) to relay such a "critique". I hate to say it, but though Libiran's Tribu didn't fully capture my attention for its uniqueness, it gave me a passion for what filmmakers do..."painting a canvass". And that he did very successfully.

Oggs, not to dote on an issue of personal being, but you seem to be a very intelligent person, however, the past 14 movie film critiques that you have novelized seem to have been too disected. How do you watch a movie? Isn't it just as simple as "watching" it? I feel that you overly extend your arm too far in that cookie jar. What's in front of you is the palette? Don't think too hard. You can't enjoy a piece that way.. Or hell, maybe you are enjoying it that way you do.. So be it... To each his own.

Kid's comments are to submerge a feeling of distaste to what he or she might think are not tooinformedbeings... A compassion towards the filmmaker's hard work.. Yes, we get that. Yes, he/she thinks that the blood, sweat, and tears, are not easily absolved.. but should be chizzled to our member. We feel it, but understanding it is another.

First, Cinemalaya is not a film festival. It is merely a week of screenings. A film festival is not Cinemalaya, Cinamanila, nor Manila Film Festival...it's pure egotist market fest. A film festival is where filmmakers are... As a jury member myself to two reputable film festivals, how I only wish that these so called events were different... for the sake of the young filmmakers who would like to be the Filmmakers of the future... A Filipino I am... A Filipino I quote... Second, Tribu does deserve a prize. Can't compare it to any other works because it is merely an entitiy of its own...like any other films... Third and last, Tribu can't be any better than what it is... if it were different...then it wouldn't be Tribu now would it?

The Philippines have two idealistic societies; those of power and those of not.. How you define that power is all up to you.. Oggs, absorb both and this whole thing will eventually make sense to you.

Peace.

"Nothing can combine better judgement than just a simple scroll from a pencil and a fold from a paper."-Jurassa Hasmin "Power"- 1967



Oggs Cruz:

Thanks for that piece of education, Rich (which shook me to my core),

I am aware of the vast differences between all filmmakers, or directors when do directors graduate to become filmmakers; is this a canonical concept; a cinematic sanctification?). As for comparisons, I use them as measurements, as gauges, as points in this vast cinematic history. I don’t claim my comparisons are objective or academic (sometimes I re-read my writings, and I cringe as to the mistakes I’ve made in the past); these are hunches (you may refer to them as intellectual masturbation), wherein a cinematic image turns on a stimulus that instantly refers to that point of cinematic history, as known to me. I agree with you that a filmmaker and a film is unique; and I also agree that to change a film to subscribe to anybody’s wishes is to completely modify the film (but this brings in to mind the very contemporary concept of director’s cuts, producer’s cuts, and many more --- are these different films; which film is whose?).

I look at films as pieces of literature --- all open to criticism, interpretation, interpolation, and discussion. My “reviews” are open to immense criticism (overextending my arm too far in that cookie jar, as you’ve said), I look at each and every detail and subscribe meaning, fault, praise to those observations (the same way I excite myself over words authors choose in writing their books --- despite the fact that these words may not be the author’s but the proofreader’s). Is that a fault, to some yes; but to me, it isn’t (it’s as overly reaching as feminist, psychoanalytic or Marxist reading). I’m turning the films I watch into a personal experience; addressing some moments I enjoy or hated with interpretations and probably rationalizations. We’re human because we think; Sorry, I don’t subscribe to the philosophy of merely watching movies --- like paintings which tell stories despite its perpetual immobility, films are evolving (the same way trash films of the past are given their due in the present).

Let me make this clear. I enjoyed Tribu. I was angry when Jim Libiran told the story about CCP and the Tondo rappers. I admire how Libiran turned Tondo into a sprawling landscape where day and night are vastly different. I used Altman as a point of reference because of Libiran’s ability to merge stories that flow with the film’s narrative (half-hearted because I’m sure Altman wasn’t the inspiration; probably from his own experiences and made literary by his workshops with Bing Lao). Meirelles, I used, because it just reminded me of that film and it does tread similarly to City of God --- whether it be intentional or not, is not a matter of concern.

So why did it seem that I disliked the movie; because of how it culminated. And that’s where I agree to your point that if it ended differently, it wouldn’t be the Tribu that is admired for “its grand and graphic depiction of contemporary Tondo, its raw passion and searing violence, its terrible social conditions and conflicting social mores, and its people’s coruscating embrace of both sacred and the profane, the filial and the tribal, the tender and the vicious.” To me, it’s sensationalizing… to some, it’s realistic. It’s really a matter of perception, not of taste (I don’t subscribe to tastes). If the film ended differently, would it be better; maybe, maybe not. Again, it doesn’t matter. Thousands loved the film for what it is, who am I to judge.

I take offense, however, to your statement that I am not a critic. First, I never claimed I was. I do not get paid, I am not published, I do not get invited to become jury members of film festivals (prestigious or not). But to completely nullify my aspirations is as hurtful as the one you accuse me of (of putting aside the blood, sweat, and tears of the filmmaker). I welcome people to comment in my blog (I never thought about screening comments) because I want to invite discussion to the films (or movies) and because I believe everyone is well-suited to become a critic (all you need is a brain, paper and a pen (or a computer) --- as your quotation states). Are my writings perfect? No. I have no grand delusions for them to be portals of cinematic knowledge (heck, I am not the best in the field I decided to be in (law), what more, for a hobby). However, it is not only cinema that is being revolutionized by the digital age. It is also film writing; some bloggers are happy with I LOVE OUIJA! ANG GANDA NI JUDAY!, while some would reach further interpretations. Can you fault us? I don’t think so.

In any case, thank you very much for your comment, which I highly respect. I don’t know if this will make sense to you, but it makes sense to me.

I end with this quote which addresses the new kind of criticism that evolved with the age of the computer (something I subscribe to); seriously, when the world has been shrunk to the size of a laptop and cultures are becoming more apparent to the everyday person, there will be new ways of appreciating art and film (we don’t just watch them, we think them, we live them, we breath them):

“In short, we’re living in a transitional period where enormous paradigmatic shifts should be engendering new concepts, new terms, and new kinds of analysis, evaluation, and measurement, not to mention new kinds of political and social formations, as well as new forms of etiquette. But in most cases they aren’t doing any of those things. We’re stuck with vocabularies and patterns of thinking that are still tied to the ways we were watching movies half a century ago.”
--- Jonathan Rosenbaum

Lastly, isn't referring to a film as best, comparing? As jury member to two festivals, how do you decide which wins? I'm just curious.



Rich:

By simply "watching" them Oggs. "Watchiing" them... That is a feat in itself.

In the decade that I've been in this industry...the film industry that is...the more a critic dissects a rubinized movie to its core, the more it becomes trash.. It's not a good feeling when one takes offense..? Does it? But we carry a jargon that often is mistaken for rape in beliefs. That my friend is what you need to understand. I think that your mental masturbation is quite an o.c.d. for leaving an open policy in your blog. You love to love it. You love to hate it. Hey, some people love porn. You.... love this. To each his own. One last thing, Jonathan Rosenbaum became the windy city's critic because of a painted canvas that he could never finish... and that my friend is to each his own.



Oggs Cruz:

First and foremost, may I know who the person is behind “rich?” That way, I
may know to whom I owe this re-education.

I pay deference to your experience, but not exactly to your way of thinking:

- Further clarifications, you say you simply “watch” movies. What happens afterwards? When it’s time to deliberate with your co-jury members who among the filmmakers deserve the top prize, what do you contribute? How do you watch films (it simple enjoyment, technical marvel)? More interestingly, what do you make of films, such as those by Bela Tarr, Lav Diaz, Tsai Ming-liang, etc., which if simply watched, wouldn’t amount to anything. Don’t tell me you just “watched” Lynch’s films, or Cronenberg’s horrors. I’m sorry, films aren’t simply watched. The best films are those which invite discourse; invite interaction with the audience --- which is also why a film festival is not merely a bunch of screenings, or as you wish that it is a communion of filmmakers and filmmaker-wannabes. A film festival is for everyone who wants to partake in film; whether you are a filmmaker, an aspirant, a writer, or like me, an over-thinking blogger. Belittle my experience, but when I over-think films, I find gems in trash and I find trash in conceived gems (case in point: Roger Corman’s films as opposed to Paul Haggis’ Crash).

- Your whole point is that we love different things, that there are so many schools of thought existing, and that we should be bound to respect differences and
uniqueness. I ask you this: why dismiss this writer as not a critic, or in your words… “I just don't think that, Oggs, you are.” Is it because my writings are righteous (as you say), overreaching (as you say), I approach it with a verbalistic observation (as you say). Again, mere differences in schools of thought; one can’t be judgmental with somebody else’s opinion. Criticism is simply that: forwarding an opinion.

- You put filmmakers in a pedestal; but what are films, are they simply watched, simply enjoyed. You make differences between filmmakers and directors. One thing I’ve noticed: those who canonized these filmmakers are the ones who don’t simply watch their films; they overthink, find symbolisms and relate it to their
respective fields --- that is art, and my friend, film is art --- not a mere show.

- You bring up Jonathan Rosenbaum’s history; how he became Chicago’s critic (which I don’t quite get; he became Chicago’s critic because of his failures?). That’s beside the point. My point is: there’s so much to film writing than mere watching and enjoyment. The quote I gave you simply puts into perspective my way of thinking: that there are many discourses in film (and not only the filmmakers, which you give undivided importance to: half of filmmaking belongs to the audience, to those who process the films and make them their own by relating it to personal experiences). I am not part of the industry, as you speak (and I do not hope to be part of it, if it means sacrificing my personal beliefs for mere enjoyment), but I hope I am part of the burgeoning film culture (which includes both filmmakers, film lovers, and everyone in between) that the internet is sparking. Film is democracy; the filmmaker doesn’t have a definite say as to what his films mean once he releases it to the public. Film isn’t merely consumed, it is experienced (and that’s how criticism should be; a remuneration of film as assessed by the critic’s own experiences, beliefs, and knowledge).

- I repeat… the independent revolution does not merely belong to the filmmakers. It belongs to everyone who loves film. Now that our filmmakers are unbound from the commercialism of the dying Philippine cinema, they are beginning to make films that matter, that aren’t simply “watched.” That’s when the audience needs to be unshackled from the bamboozlement the proliferation of Hollywood films has given us.